Posts

Showing posts with the label Toby's Mom PLL

Why TOBY might have thrown the rock at Ali on PLL ~Theory~

A fan on my facebook page, sent me a few questions about the possibility of Toby being the person who threw the rock at Ali, as we saw somebody do in the season 4 finale of "Pretty Little Liars." While we wait for PLL to return tomorrow night, I figured I'd post those questions and my answers/opinions here!

*FAN Q&A with Noelene Peters. My answers are in bold. Please weigh in, in the comments!*
.
.
.
.
"There are a lot of Theories going around that A and the person that hit Ali are two different ppl

I think Toby is the one that hit Ali he may have thanked her for saving him from Jenna because he didn't want Ali to catch on to him that he hates her and her friends (in a flash black Ali went to see him and he told her he wish he knew who sent the notes so he can join and help) I think Toby is helping A from season one and he has never been a good guy." 

Regarding the juvie flashback and Toby removing himself from Ali's suspect list--

According to Alison's …

I Know What You Did..To Toby's Mom & Ali -PLL Theory

--This theory involves the TV show PLL/Pretty Little Liars. It explores the possibility that Jessica DiLaurentis protecting the person who threw the rock at Ali is RELATED TO TOBY'S MOTHER'S DEATH.-- 
~features: Wilden, Jessica, Peter Hastings, Ali, Jason, blackmail & more~

Let's think about what we know about Jessica DiLaurentis aside from her creepiness. We know that she saw who threw the rock at Alison in attempt to kill her. Additionally, instead of calling the police like your average mother would do in this situation, that Jessica buried Alison in her backyard. There has to be a good reason that Jessica didn't call the police, and maybe it's because a police officer was already present at the scene of the crime. Perhaps Wilden threw the rock at Alison.

A lot of fans are assuming that since Jessica chose to protect the person who threw the rock at Ali, that the person must be someone related to and/or very close to Jessica. However, we could be dealing with…